Transparency Is a Priority
Catholic bishops who protected pedophile priests and failed to prevent child abuse are accomplices to their crimes. It is wrong for this negligence to go unpunished. To this effect, the Vatican took a positive step yesterday by assuming the responsibility to evaluate and punish leaders whose behavior does not live up to their hierarchy.
Pope Francis denounced the issue of child abuse within the Church from day one. His appointment carried on with the changes initiated by Pope Benedict XVI regarding the passivity that characterized Pope John Paul II’s term.
The new internal process, geared to culminate with a revamped and much-feared Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith ‒which now includes a judicial body ‒ was created to oversee the behavior of priests and to discipline them if needed. This emphasis on the gargantuan problem of child abuse reveals Pope Francis’ stiff, zero-tolerance stance regarding the issue while maintaining the Church’s traditional method of dealing with its problems internally.
This is a positive step but it does not ensure that the Vatican will be as firm as expected. The designation of Bishop Juan Barros Madrid to the Diocese of Osorno in Chile caused uproar due to his close relationship with a fellow priest who has been accused of a number of sexual abuses. The same feeling of outrage arose when Scottish Cardinal Keith O’Brien stepped down because of sexual misconduct. While O’Brien lost his rights and privileges as cardinal, he is still an active priest and a retired bishop.
This special treatment reinforces the argument that priests and bishops who are somehow linked with sexual child abuse cases should face justice locally instead of being delegated to a religious jurisdiction where they will be punished as the institution sees fit.
If it is transparent, the new system could help the Church repair its image by eliminating the perception that it helps the accused to evade local justice and covers up their offenses. If it is not, the disillusionment will be even greater.